avatar quantumrealityssaidthis

Comment and replies on Xtorrent:

avatar

by
quantumrealitys, 2006-12-26

Consistently screws up all downloads and i have to start all over from the beginning. Can't seem to "remember" the external hard drive i'm downloading to. Lame but pretty.

avatar

by
adc89, 2007-03-06

Still no encryption... There is no way I'm paying for a bittorrent client w/o encryption.

avatar

by
xyz, 2007-03-20 (score: 2)

Frankly xTorrent is a bit of a mess, not as reliable as Transmission and with a pretty but complete overblown interface. The Torrentcast feature is fantastic though and should be in every Bittorrent client.

avatar

by
mikesolis, 2007-03-27 (score: 11)

This program is even worse at nagging you to buy it than acquisition and newsfire combined: a 10 kb/s cap after using the program after a 1 hour time limit, and search results are randomly disabled, plus a window that you can't close uless you click on either the "purcahse" button or the "activate" button. This program is great looking and somewhat useful and I almost switched to it from Transmission because of the built in search and RSS features. Once I downloaded the 1.0, however, these nags totally turned me off. How useless is a torrent app that caps the bandwith after an hour!

avatar

by
factoryjoe, 2007-05-24 (score: 1)

I upgraded to v41 and it lost all my in-progress downloads. Not sure what happened there, but upgrade with caution (backup first!).

Otherwise, I love xTorrent -- but I also paid for it.

avatar

by
groxx, 2007-05-25 (score: 2)

When this first went shareware, I wrote an applescript that restarts it every 59 minutes, and hides the app. Works pretty well, then, and avoids the speed capping. From what I remember, it wasn't too complicated (as it was my first actual applescript I've ever made), but I deleted it when I stopped using this app (switched to Transmission).
All in all, a pretty good program. Not the best, but gets a pretty good download speed, and the search function is incredibly handy.
The only real downside I can see is that you can't retrieve .torrent files from the program. Once it's in, it's in for good, and there's no way to back them up.

avatar

by
austinnate, 2007-07-04 (score: 7)

Buyer beware!!!! NO SUPPORT!!!!

avatar

by
ocm, 2007-07-11 (score: 6)

First off why would you want to pay for a bittorrent client. Especially one with all the flaws xtorrent has (banned from many trackers etc).

Secondly why use xtorrent when transmission is basically the same and free(ok xtorrent has a few more things but at the core its just transmission). Im not going to pay someone else when all they have done is put a wrapper around open source code.

I would rather support the transmission guys instead of someone who takes there code, uses it in a shareware app, then completely tries to hide the fact they have done so(ever noticed there is not a single mention of libtransmission anywhere on the xtorrent site).

avatar

by
kenshoberlin, 2007-07-15

I like David´s apps a lot and so I happily paid for the full version of Xtorrent. The integrated search and RSS-Feeds really make downloading over Bittorrent a breeze. However, lately I had to go back to Transmission to download a file which Xtorrent did not want to finish downloading (looks like the most recent version introduced a couple of bugs). Transmission has really come a long way since i last had a look at it - and i guess i would recommend it over Xtorrent these days.

avatar

by
ocm, 2007-08-08 (score: 5)

From the transmission forum about licensing changes - "Portions of the code will be changed to avoid blatant attempts to profit significantly from our work"

Seems some of the parts that changed to a gpl license are the same bits added to the latest version of xtorrent. Which means xtorrent should be open source to comply with the license.

avatar

by
marcus, 2007-08-08

or they will have to fork libtransmission

avatar

by
pimodan, 2007-08-15

david watanabe is the karl rove of mac software development: an extremist, far right minded person that profits from the work of people with a very different approach and belief in softw. develpment. he copied once limewire, and he copied now transmission. beautiful app, but the karl rove of app. won't have my vote.

avatar

by
aezell, 2007-09-01 (score: 9)

This torrent client has been banned by a large majority of torrent trackers. Apparently, it's a pretty shoddy implementation of a very old version of libtransmission. In addition, the trackers seem to think the spirit of the developer doesn't fit with their vision of the torrent community.

Use at your own risk.

avatar

by
bruce, 2007-09-01 (score: 11)

OCM, I expect Watanabe won't open source Xtorrent. He's happy to profit from it, but he'll never contribute. He'll leave continue using the older version of libtransmission to avoid having to abide by the modified license. He'll just keep throwing more new features into the app to distract people from the fact that the heart of his app is ancient and limited. That or he'll brazenly use it and ignore the license, proving once and for all everything bad that's ever been said about him.

A friend of mine uses this because of the torrent search feature. I've tried to tell him to use Azureus or Transmission, but he likes the search.

avatar

by
lest78, 2008-01-25 (score: 1)

I use xTorrent like a demon, I honestly love this app. Everyone bitches and moans about it and the creator, even I have been kn own to (Watanabe, would it hurt you to reply to e-mails that are genuine customer suppoprt related?)... and as for it being banned from torrent sites... I've never not found anything I wanted using it's built in search feature.

At the end of the day, I honestly love this app.

avatar

by
kangorillas, 2008-02-07 (score: 1)

This app has it's pretty cool features I must admit. But overall not worth the buy and it's also kinda buggy.

avatar

by
rubenscd, 2008-04-15 (score: -4)

Please new version !!! Upgrade Now !!!

1 2 next

Page 1 of 2. 34 entries.